Who Values Democracy?
Max Miller · Journal of Political Economy 134(12), December 2026, forthcoming · 10.1086/743899
Abstract. This paper examines the conventional view that redistribution is central to the democratization process using data from stock markets. Consistent with this view, democratizations have a large, negative impact on asset valuations driven by a rise in redistribution risk. Across 90 countries over 200 years, risk premia are substantially elevated — similar in magnitude to financial crises — prior to and during democratizations. A shift in Catholic church doctrine in support of democracy provides causal evidence that democratizations increase risk premia. Successful democratizations lead to substantial redistribution: the size of the public sector grows, income inequality falls, and the labor share of income rises. An extended version of the canonical redistribution-based model of democratization that includes asset prices can quantitatively explain these effects. Reductions in inequality and increased taxes explain approximately half of the results. The rest comes from greater economic competition and equality in government spending. The model also explains the negligible asset pricing response to autocratizations. Neither an increase in macroeconomic risk nor generic political risk can explain the results.
Key findings
Dividend yields rise by 19 percent around a democratization, similar in magnitude to what we see in financial crises. The data cover 90 countries over 200 years. Stock prices in autocracies mostly reflect the views of wealthy owners of capital, so they show how elites judge a transition as it happens.
A shift in Catholic Church doctrine in favor of democracy raised average excess stock returns by 6.3 to 12.5 percentage points in majority-Catholic autocracies. The shift, from 1959 to 1963, made democratization more likely in those countries for reasons outside their own economies. The estimates show no pre-trends.
In the model, greater economic competition drives 41.5 percent of the rise in dividend yields. Higher taxes, lower inequality and less corruption drive the other 58.5 percent. The model adds asset prices to the theory of democratization in Acemoglu and Robinson (2006). Calibrated to the redistribution seen in the data, it explains nearly all of the rise in dividend yields.
Press
- Marginal Revolution: Who Values Democracy?
- HBS Working Knowledge: Why Markets Panic When Democracy Spreads
- Harvard Business School News: Behind the Research: Max Miller
- Harvard Kennedy School, Center for International Development: How Democracy Shapes Financial Markets
Cite
Miller, Max. “Who Values Democracy?” Journal of Political Economy 134, no. 12 (December 2026), forthcoming. https://doi.org/10.1086/743899
@article{miller2026democracy,
author = {Miller, Max},
title = {Who Values Democracy?},
journal = {Journal of Political Economy},
year = {2026},
volume = {134},
number = {12},
note = {Forthcoming},
doi = {10.1086/743899}
}
Replication
The replication data are on Harvard Dataverse: 10.7910/DVN/EEFXAT.
Other versions
The working paper is on SSRN. The paper formerly circulated under the title “Democratization, Inequality, and Risk Premia.”